|SMBL has reported its first quarter results. They beat the consensus analyst estimates for their sales numbers ($50.8 million vs. 49.79 million) but appear to have fallen short on the earnings estimates (a $1.2 million GAAP loss vs. break even).|
Smart Balance Announces 2008 First-Quarter Results
Wednesday May 7, 8:30 am ET
- Net sales $50.8 million, up 25% versus year ago on operating basis (1)
- Gross profit margin 45% - despite historic high commodity costs
- Net loss $1.2 million, includes non-cash charges of $3.2 million
- 2008 Outlook - Targeted 30% growth in net sales on operating basis (1)
PARAMUS, N.J., May 7 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Smart Balance Inc. (Nasdaq: SMBL - News) today announced its results for the first quarter ended March 31, 2008. The Company reported net sales of $50.8 million, an increase of 25.1% versus year ago on an operating basis(1), and a net loss of $1.2 million, reflecting the $3.2 million after-tax impact of non-cash items, including $2.1 million of stock-based compensation expense and $1.1 million of amortization and depreciation. The net loss was $0.02 on both diluted and basic shares.
Gross profit margin was 45.0%, as the rate of selling price increases lagged the rate of input cost increases, reflecting historic high levels in commodity raw materials. Selling prices in the Company's core category of spreads were increased in February and the Company has announced additional price increases to take effect in June.
The Company continued the recapitalization of its balance sheet with the January conversion of its preferred stock to common stock. In March, an additional $30 million of cash was used to pay down debt. Long-term debt was $89.5 million on March 31, 2008, down $70.5 million (44%) since the acquisition of GFA Brands Inc. in May, 2007.
"We continue to make excellent progress executing against our strategy, despite the unprecedented cost environment," said Stephen B. Hughes, Smart Balance Chairman and CEO. "We increased market share in spreads for the 25th consecutive quarter and had a record quarter in sales, growing 25%."
The Company continued to expand distribution with 'Plus Six', its initiative to increase average items on shelf at retail from 12 to a target of 18 by the end of June. Smart Balance has also forged a strategic agreement with Ventura Foods, Inc. to develop, market and distribute Smart Balance branded products in the foodservice channel.
"I believe the retail commitments on 'Plus Six' and Butter Blends national launch are exceptional, with key customers expanding our placements by 50% or more," said Hughes. "We expect accelerating growth in the second half of 2008 once the retail store resets are completed by July."
(1) In addition to its GAAP results, the Company has provided operating basis results to explain year-over-year changes. The operating basis results should not be viewed in isolation or as a substitute for GAAP results. A reconciliation of operating basis results to GAAP results is provided in the accompanying tables.
Change in Accounting Principles
In 2008, the Company began accruing for certain trade incentives and marketing costs as prepaid expenses to better match recognition of expense to revenue, consistent with the general practice in the consumer product goods industry. This methodology is a change from prior years. While this methodology may create timing differences between prior year's quarters on an operating basis, it has no impact on full year results. In accordance with FAS No. 154, a retrospective application of the change in accounting principle is being applied to 2007 quarterly results to improve comparability. This retroactive application is already reflected in the Company's discussion of results on an operating basis for the first quarter. The Company anticipates publishing the changes to the other quarters in the near future.
2008 First Quarter GAAP Results
The Company indicated that its reported GAAP financial statements include the results of its acquisition of GFA Brands, Inc. since the date of acquisition on May 21, 2007. Because there were no operations prior to the acquisition, prior periods are not comparable. The Company has provided results on an operating basis following the GAAP results. The operating basis results should not be viewed in isolation or as a substitute for reported GAAP results. A reconciliation of operating basis results to GAAP results is provided for in the accompanying tables.
Net sales were $50.8 million for the first quarter. Operating income was $2.0 million, which included $4.6 million of non-cash charges. First quarter net loss was $1.2 million. The $30 million in debt pay down required a cash prepayment penalty of $0.6 million, reflected in pretax interest expense. In addition, the debt prepayment accelerated $0.9 million of deferred financing amortization, reflected in pretax other expense net. See the tables below for the non-cash items affecting operating income and net loss. Net loss for the quarter was $0.02 on a per share basis, both diluted and basic.
Items Affecting GAAP Operating Income - 2008
$ in Millions First Quarter
Operating Income 2.0
Non-cash charges affecting Operating Income:
FAS 123R Stock Option Expense (3.5)
Depreciation & Amortization (1.1)
Operating Income less non-cash charges 6.6
Items Affecting GAAP Net Loss - 2008
$ in Millions First Quarter
Net Loss (1.2)
Non-cash charges after-tax affecting Net Loss:
FAS 123R Stock Option Expense (2.1)
Depreciation & Amortization (0.6)
Accelerated Financing Amortization (0.5)
Net Loss less non-cash charges after-tax 2.0
2008 First Quarter Operating Basis Results
The following discussion of operating basis results includes the operating results of Smart Balance Inc. from the date of its acquisition of GFA Brands, Inc. on May 21, 2007 and the operating results of GFA Brands prior to the acquisition. Management believes that this presentation provides more useful information because it reflects the performance of the operating entity in both the current and prior periods presented. The operating basis results should not be viewed in isolation or as a substitute for reported GAAP results. A reconciliation of operating basis results to GAAP results is provided in the accompanying tables.
Net sales increased 25.1% to $50.8 million in 2008, from $40.6 million in 2007, due to higher prices across almost all categories and a 10% increase in case volume. The case increase was due to shipments of new products (extra virgin olive oil spreads, omega-3 enhanced spreads, 50/50 butter blend, milk and cream cheese) and higher sales of peanut butter. The gains in prices and volume were partially offset by higher trade and promotion costs.
Both dollar and volume market shares for spreads increased versus the prior year for the 25th consecutive quarter. During the Easter promotion period, the Company raised promoted prices to maintain margins in step with the February price increase, while the category generally kept previous holiday pricing levels in place. As anticipated, this resulted in a lower holiday performance at retail for Smart Balance products in March. Market shares for peanut butter and cooking oil also increased while mayonnaise and popcorn declined.
Gross profit increased $2.9 million to $22.8 million in 2008 from $19.9 million in 2007 as the impacts of higher pricing and sales volume were greater than increases in input costs and trade related spending. Gross profit as a percent of net sales decreased to 45.0% in 2008 from 49.1% in the first quarter of 2007, as the rate of selling price increases lagged the rate of input costs increases, primarily in commodity raw materials
Operating income declined $6.2 million to $2.0 million in 2008 from $8.2 million in 2007 as the gain in gross profit was more than offset by increased selling costs and general and administrative expenses. Selling costs increased $1.6 million due to higher overhead, warehouse and freight costs. General and administrative expenses increased $7.2 million primarily due to higher infrastructure costs and non-cash expenses of $3.5 million in FAS 123R Stock Option expense, and $1.1 million for depreciation and amortization. Excluding these non-cash charges, operating income would have declined $1.6 million to $6.6 million in 2008 from $8.2 million in 2007.
Smart Balance's outlook for 2008 continues to reflect growth in net sales on an operating basis in line with its long-term target of approximately 30%. Progressively increasing distribution through the Company's 'Plus Six' drive will be supported by the innovations in its core category: extra virgin olive oil spreads, omega-3 enhanced spreads and 50/50 butter blend. The Company expects that the second half of 2008 will see accelerating sales growth as a result of these initiatives. Pricing actions include the increase that was effective in February 2008 and the announced increase for June 2008. Gross profit as a percent of net sales will be lower in 2008 versus 2007 as pricing actions are expected to continue to trail rising input costs. Marketing investments are expected to increase in order to support growth. Infrastructure costs increases versus prior year will diminish as 2008 progresses. The Company also expects to continue to meet all covenants related to long-term debt.
SMART BALANCE, INC. AND SUBSIDIARY
Consolidated Balance Sheets
March 31, December 31,
Cash and cash equivalents $7,032,468 $37,648,754
Accounts receivable, net of allowance
2008- $226,891 and 2007-$228,871 11,827,242 11,733,117
Accounts receivable - other 1,190,127 799,470
Inventories 7,676,319 7,202,198
Prepaid expenses and other assets 5,743,983 1,454,866
Deferred tax asset 1,079,509 1,079,509
Total current assets 42,618,388 66,435,747
Property and equipment, net 2,628,319 1,805,331
Goodwill 374,885,923 374,885,923
Other intangibles, net 158,273,243 159,645,634
Deferred costs, net 2,559,021 3,519,412
Other assets 113,882 74,975
Total other assets 535,832,069 538,125,944
Total assets $581,078,776 $606,367,022
Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity
Accounts payable and accrued expenses $22,699,613 $20,355,419
Income taxes payable 1,050,149 1,035,149
Total current liabilities 23,749,762 21,390,568
Long term debt 89,504,174 119,504,174
Deferred tax liability 53,293,528 53,293,528
Other liabilities 35,626 --
Total liabilities 166,583,090 194,188,270
Commitment and contingencies:
Series A Convertible Preferred stock,
$.0001 par value, 50,000,000 shares
authorized; 15,388,889 preferred shares
converted into 19,516,832 shares of common
stock on January 3, 2008 -- 175,659,013
Common stock, $.0001 par value,
250,000,000 shares authorized; 62,630,683
(March 31, 2008) and 43,113,863
(December 31, 2007) issued and
outstanding 6,263 4,311
Additional paid in capital 494,631,114 315,479,759
Retained deficit (80,141,691) (78,964,331)
Total stockholders' equity 414,495,686 412,178,752
Total liabilities and stockholders' equity $581,078,776 $606,367,022
SMART BALANCE, INC. AND SUBSIDIARY
Consolidated Statements of Operations
Three months Three months
March 31, 2008 March 31, 2007
Net sales $50,765,739 $ --
Cost of goods sold 27,938,186 --
Gross profit 22,827,553 --
Marketing 7,225,344 --
Selling 5,056,418 --
General and administrative 8,583,697 --
Formation and operating costs -- 672,873
Total operating expenses 20,865,459 672,873
Operating income (loss) 1,962,094 (672,873)
Other income (expense):
Interest income 251,360 1,078,207
Interest expense (3,231,721) --
Loss on derivative liability -- (7,784,112)
Other (expense), net (944,000) --
Total other income (expense) (3,924,361) (6,705,905)
(Loss) before income taxes (1,962,267) (7,378,778)
Provision (benefit) for income taxes (784,907) 148,183
Net (loss) $(1,177,360) $(7,526,961)
(Loss) per share:
Basic $(0.02) $(0.52)
Diluted $(0.02) $(0.52)
Weighted average shares outstanding:
Basic 62,196,988 14,355,945
Diluted 62,196,988 14,355,945
Smart Balance, Inc.
Operating Basis Results(1)
(in 000's) Three Months Three Months
March 31, 2008 March 31, 2007
Net Sales $50,766 $40,583
COGS 27,938 20,672
Gross Profit 22,828 19,911
Gross margins 45.0% 49.1%
Marketing 7,225 6,901
Selling 5,057 3,450
G&A 8,584 1,403
Total SG&A 20,866 11,754
Operating Income 1,962 8,157
% of Net Sales 3.9% 20.1%
Operating Income includes the following
FAS 123R Stock Options 3,534 --
Depreciation 53 6
Amortization 1,022 --
Operating Income net of non-cash items: 6,571 8,163
% of Net Sales 12.9% 20.1%
(1) The Company's GAAP financial statements include the results of its acquisition of GFA Brands, Inc. since the date of acquisition on May 21, 2007. Because there were no operations prior to the acquisition, prior periods are not comparable. The operating basis results should not be viewed in isolation or as a substitute for reported GAAP results. Please refer to the reconciliation of operating basis results to GAAP results provided for in the accompanying table.
Smart Balance, Inc. Reconciliation of Operating Basis to GAAP Basis
Prior to Smart Balance, Inc.'s May 21, 2007 acquisition of GFA Brands Inc., operating income consisted largely of formation costs and other expenses incurred in seeking and evaluating potential business combinations. We have added these expenses back to the operating basis results below, as GFA incurred its own operating expenses for these periods, and the inclusion of the parent company's expenses prior to the date of acquisition make it difficult to compare operating results period to period. Additionally, in 2008, the Company began accruing for certain trade incentives and marketing costs as prepaid expense to better match recognition of expense to revenue. While this methodology may create timing differences between prior year's quarters on an operating basis, it has no impact on full year results. A retrospective application of the change in accounting principle is being applied to 2007 quarterly results to improve comparability. With the information set forth below, management and stockholders would be better able to determine whether or not sales or operating income of the acquired business have improved in 2008 compared with prior periods. The operating basis results provided below are intended to assist the reader in comparing the operating performance of the GFA business we acquired, for the periods before and after the acquisition. However, they do not indicate what consolidated results would have been had we acquired GFA on January 1, 2007.
The operating basis results should not be viewed in isolation or as a substitution for GAAP results.
GAAP Basis Operating Basis
($ in 000's)
Add GFA (2)
Three Months Ended As reported Results For Add Operating
March 31, 2008 Form 10-Q the Period Adjustments Basis
Net Sales 50,766 -- -- 50,766
Operating Income 1,962 -- -- 1,962
Three Months Ended As reported Results For Add Operating
March 31, 2007 Form 10-Q the Period Adjustments Basis
Net Sales -- 40,583 -- 40,583
Operating Income (673) 8,157 673 8,157
(1) To add GFA results for the entire reporting period as necessary
(2) To remove parent company pre-acquisition expenses from the results prior to the acquisition date, May 21, 2007.
Source: Smart Balance Inc.