Coffee Shop | Bob Brinker: Bad Calls & Good Calls


Previous 10 | Next 10 
To: TREND1 who started this subject7/18/2003 10:30:12 PM
From: TREND1   of 133
 
Just added another "never sell" from Bob Brinker
AWE
Source was an email. Email used 4/27/2001. I used 4/27/2000
from Yahoo Historical data.

investorshub.com 

Larry Dudash

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read

To: TREND1 who wrote (115)7/19/2003 1:27:13 PM
From: ladytrade   of 133
 
Thanks for the warning, Larry. I think if he warns on the market itself, that it might be taken as a sell signal for the stocks. Don't you?

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read | Read Replies (1)

To: ladytrade who wrote (117)7/19/2003 2:49:35 PM
From: TREND1   of 133
 
ladytrade
you wrote
I think if he warns on the market itself, that it might be taken as a sell signal for the stocks. Don't you?


answer:
That is a good way to handle it.IMHO.
Maybe you should have a "percentage stop loss" too.IMHO.
Bob has never placed a "SELL XYZ" in his newsletter as far
as I can tell.

Larry Dudash

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read | Read Replies (1)

To: TREND1 who wrote (118)7/19/2003 5:36:11 PM
From: ladytrade   of 133
 
Larry: Do you know for a fact that when BB called the bear market in 2000 that he didn't tell people to sell? There was a time I heard a few of his radio shows and I got the idea from the callers that he'd saved their bacon, that they'd sold out as a result of his call of the bull market top?

In any case, it would be inconsistent to accept his call of the end of a bull market, and not to sell your stocks, wouldn't it?

On the matter of stop losses, how would you calculate the price of the stop loss order? I've been toying with placing some.

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read | Read Replies (1)

To: ladytrade who wrote (119)7/19/2003 5:45:32 PM
From: TREND1   of 133
 
ladytrade: You wrote:
Larry: Do you know for a fact that when BB called the bear market in 2000 that he didn't tell people to sell? There was a time I heard a few of his radio shows and I got the idea from the callers that he'd saved their bacon, that they'd sold out as a result of his call of the bull market top?

answer:
Actually Bob Brinker did an asset reallocation.
(1)Sell 60% of your holdings.
(2)Keep 40% of your holdings.(This 40% was later changed to 35%)
(3)Do not recall any "sell this or that stock"
That was left up to use to sell 60 cents on the dollar.IMHO.
..........................................................
In any case, it would be inconsistent to accept his call of the end of a bull market, and not to sell your stocks, wouldn't it?

answer:
See above
.........................................................

On the matter of stop losses, how would you calculate the price of the stop loss order? I've been toying with placing some.

answer:
SORRY.Like Bob, I am not going to give you any advice of how to do stop losses.
.........................................................
Your questions were very good.IMHO.

Larry Dudash

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read | Read Replies (1)

To: TREND1 who wrote (120)7/19/2003 6:23:27 PM
From: ladytrade   of 133
 
This conversation between us has gone wrong twice now. I will not be posting in this thread again. You can try as often as you like, but I won't respond in this thread again.

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read

To: TREND1 who started this subject7/19/2003 8:36:36 PM
From: TREND1   of 133
 
Final Conclusions dated 7/19/03

Part 1. What to expect from Bob Brinker's Major Buys and Sells.
Bob Brinker's major calls are in general very good.IMHO.
(a)Buy when he says major buy.IMHO.
(b)Sell when he says sell.IMHO.
(c)Do not use his sells to go short.IMHO.
(d)Allocation is still a problem.IMHO.

Part 2. What to expect from Bob Brinker's stock/Fund buys.
(a)You must decide before hand the risk you are willing to take.IMHO.
(b)And be prepared to take firm Stop Loss action rather
then depend on Bob's sell.

Take a look at numbers and make up your own mind.
investorshub.com 


Larry Dudash

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read

To: TREND1 who started this subject7/19/2003 8:37:14 PM
From: TREND1   of 133
 
THIS BOARD IS CLOSED !
Larry Dudash

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read

To: TREND1 who started this subject7/20/2003 12:39:52 AM
From: lizardK   of 133
 
Hey Larry, can you spell ROOF JOB? LOL!!!

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read

To: TREND1 who started this subject7/20/2003 12:32:36 PM
From: TREND1   of 133
 
THIS BOARD IS CLOSED !
Larry Dudash

Share Recommend | Keep | Reply | Mark as Last Read
Previous 10 | Next 10 

Copyright © 1995-2013 Knight Sac Media. All rights reserved.