Search: I put here, for anyone interested, an unoptimized sample of the zillions of things that come up when I look for information around the question of whether or not Live Search sucks relative to Google. I have found out that
1) Search is an infinite world, I'm never gonna get a true overview. Here are symbols of that:
searchengineworld.com 
This is msft's in house search blog
blogs.msdn.com 
2) There do not seem to be "benchmark" tests to evaluate searches, not a surprise.
3) I did not find clear evidence that Google whomps Live, which is itself, to me, evidence to the contrary. Here are some items consistent with this view.
This one is two (=infty in search) years old, but supports my hypothesis that Live is competitive:
"All in all, Live.com’s effort is much more creative and head turning than what Google seems to be testing. Others might argue, of course, that Google’s clean interface has served them (and us) very well over the years and needs little, if any, tweaks at this time. As Live.com becomes more responsive and faster, it will be interesting to see if people drift away from Google Search and over to Live.com."
from
techcrunch.com 
"We have to say, Google is still tops in our book for default web searches -- but Live's Academic search is pretty awesome. It totally blows Google Scholar out of the water."
from
downloadsquad.com 
which contains the reader comments (check them all online)
RP said...
I use Google, but Live also wins on Maps, where they have a very impressive "BirdsEye View" feature. It blows away Google's street view.
Eros said...
Also Live image & video search are way batter then google's
burnblue said...
Google Image Search doesn't have a very refined or useful interface, so Live wins there. Just a couple days ago Live Maps helped me find what I needed (nearby restaurants) when Google wasn't being very helpful, so Microsoft wins there again. Even Ask.com's default search results page offers quicker answers than Google quite often for certain types of searches. So why is Google's search still cooler/easier? Is it purely habit?
Check the reader comments from
downloadsquad.com 
One more:
Microsoft launches Live Search News, Google News killer?
searchenginejournal.com 
It's a jungle, I know. :)
MP |